
Throwing Copper
Radioactive
1995
In “Selling the Drama” the narrator compares the institutions of government and religion and condemns them for uniformly manipulating the crowd that keeps them in power.
And to love: a god, and to fear: a flame
And to burn a crowd that has a name
And to right or wrong
And to meek or strong
It is known
Just scream it from the wall
I've willed, I've walked, I've read
I've talked, I know, I know,
I've been here before
Hey, now we won't be raped
Hey, now we won't be scarred like that
It's the sun that burns
It's the wheel that turns
It's the way we sing that
Makes 'em dream
And to christ: a cross
And to me: a chair
I will sit and earn the ransom
From up here
I've willed, I've walked, I've read
I've talked, I know, I know,
I've been here before
Hey, now we won't be raped
Hey, now we won't be scarred like that
And to love: a god
And to fear: a flame
And to burn a love that has a name
I've willed, I've walked, I've read
I've talked, I know, I know,
I've been here before
Hey, now we won't be raped
Hey, now we won't be scarred like that
Interpretation
And to love: a god
And to fear: a flame
And to burn a crowd
That has a name
The song opens with three indictments against the institutions of government and religion. The first describes “love” manifested as patriotism and trust directed at a man (politician or pastor) who becomes like “a god” to us. The second refers to the power of coercion held by each leader. “Flame” evokes images of a bomb to illustrate a politician's military coercion. “Flame” also refers to a religious leaders coercive leverage in hell. If a person threatens the institution, a religious leader can resort to condemning their actions as sinful and worthy of hell. The third is a statement about the constant broken promises made to “the crowd” during elections. “The crowd” is burned when the elected politician forgets these promises. In the religious perspective, Christ's promises of redemption and forgiveness are forgotten in the way these leaders present the gospel as one of heaven for a few and eternal torment for the many.And to right or wrong
And to meek or strong
It is known
Just scream it from the wall
This stanza describes the social Darwinism prevalent in our politics and religion. “Right or wrong” are things we decide on based on what benefits us the most. “Meek or strong” describes the winners (the “strong”) and the losers (“the meek”) in this survival of the fittest struggle. This becomes clear in the final two lines. The western world is further convinced of capitalism’s superiority because of the collapse of communism epitomized by the fall of the Berlin Wall in 1989. The narrator rhetorically asks, what is right or wrong and who is meek or strong? Just look at how we prevailed in the Cold War. “It is known” who is right and strong. We “scream it from the [Berlin] wall”. Because we defeated communism our way of life is obviously superior. Our political and religious leaders repeat this idea until we accept it as true.I've willed, I've walked, I've read
I've talked, I know, I know,
I've been here before
In this stanza the narrator describes how he has gone beyond blind trust in political and religious institutions. He has thought independently (“willed”), experienced life outside of institutional control (“walked”), educated himself (“read”), and learned from others on the same journey (“talked”). This moves him to a place of rebellion. Though he has “been here before”, meaning he has been angry and defiant before, this time he is intent on following through.Hey, now we won't be raped
Hey, now we won't be scarred like that
The chorus conveys the narrator’s insistence that the government and institutional church has blood on its hands and it is guilty of criminal offenses. That he uses the term “raped” to describe the crimes committed by these institutions is fitting in that political and religious leaders steals our freedom by demanding mindless allegiance. This requirement to be considered a good citizens of the country and the church has left us “scarred” in that our humanity has been wounded. Humans were not meant to be subjugated by other humans and as long as we are, the wound will not heal.It's the sun that burns
It's the wheel that turns
It's the way we sing that
Makes 'em dream
The narrator turns radical in this stanza. He points to “the sun” as the real life-giver and the only “flame” that we should fear. Time is the “wheel that turns” and this is a force beyond the scope of our political and religious institutions. Finally, he says that it is only at our whim that political and religious leaders “dream” or stay in power. If we “sing” a different song then we can change the course of our reality.And to Christ: a cross
And to me: a chair
I will sit and earn the ransom
From up here
This is the climax of the song. The singer compares Christ’s execution as a result of challenging political and religious institutions with the narrator’s own resistance. Christ was nailed to “a cross” for proclaiming a replacement Caesar and a budding kingdom. If Christians were true to our calling today, governments and religious groups would strap us to an electric chair. The narrator understands that to speak truth against these institutions will result in people hating him and persecuting him. He envisions this punishment as earning a “ransom”; that other people will be enabled to unplug from the system because of his example.I've willed, I've walked, I've read
I've talked, I know, I know,
I've been here before
Hey, now we won't be raped
Hey, now we won't be scarred like that
And to love: a god
And to fear: a flame
And to burn a love that has a name
The third line changes in this repeated stanza with great significance. The first two lines remain a description of the teaching of our nation and our churches; worship a man who is set up like a god (in political power and religious authority) and fear him because of the military power he has at his disposal or, in the case of the religious leader the damnation to hell he preaches against his enemies. The narrator objects to this once again but now on the grounds that those who are being “[burned]” are real people with names. They are not a faceless mob and the political and religious leaders rely on their love to remain in power. If we withdraw that love and devotion they will fall.I've willed, I've walked, I've read
I've talked, I know, I know,
I've been here before
Hey, now we won't be raped
Hey, now we won't be scarred like that